Sismondi's forgotten ethical critique of early capitalism
Journal of Business Ethics · 1984 · Volume 3 · Issue 3
Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to bring attention to Sismondi's forgotten ethical critique oflaissez-fairecapitalism. It is a forgotten critique because Sismondi has to a large extent been neglected in the literature. He has been too quickly labelled an ‘economic romanticist’. It is ethical because Sismondi questioned what he called chrematistics, which to him was becoming the chief end of economics. Chrematistics is the science of the increase of wealth conceived of abstractly and not in relation to man or society. This was opposed to the provisioning principle which Sismondi saw as the key principle of economics. To Sismondi the object of economics is man not wealth. His critique oflaissez-fairecapitalism was from this perspective. This led Sismondi to propose state containment of capitalism so that the well-being of the whole community was attained. This proposal is an alternative to Marx's complete liquidiation of capitalism. Sismondi's ethical critique is important not only from the point of view of the history of political economy but also for an insight into what values and principles should be given priority in our economic systems today.
Keywords
Economic Growth, Political Economy, Economic System, Ethical Critique, System Today
Enable JavaScript for citation tools and additional paper interactions.