Scholion.ai

A Comparison of the Lieberman-Ross and Mann-Grubbs Methods

Arthur L. Schoenstadt

Journal of the American Statistical Association · 1980 · Volume 75 · Issue 369

DOI: 10.1080/01621459.1980.10477455

Abstract

This article compares two procedures for computing reliability confidence bounds for series systems whose components have independent, exponentially distributed failure times. The Lieberman-Ross method is statistically exact, whereas the Mann-Grubbs method approximates an exact optimum bound. For test plans that involve simultaneous testing of all samples of each component type, it is shown that when the Lieberman-Ross method uses all of the observed failure data in computing the confidence bound, the resulting bound will not be practically lower than that produced by the Mann-Grubbs method. Simulation is used to infer that only when the observed data are ordered so that the observed failure times of a significant fraction of the least reliable samples are not actually used in computing the Lieberman-Ross bound can that method be expected to produce a bound superior to that produced by the Mann-Grubbs procedure, using the full data set.

Enable JavaScript for citation tools and additional paper interactions.