Case-Control Studies With Errors in Covariates
R. J. Carroll, M. H. Gail, J. H. Lubin
Journal of the American Statistical Association · 1993 · Volume 88 · Issue 421
DOI: 10.1080/01621459.1993.10594310
Abstract
We devise methods for estimating the parameters of a prospective logistic model with dichotomous response D and arbitrary covariates X from case-control data when these covariates are measured with error. We suppose that some fraction of the cases and controls provide only the error-prone covariate measurements, W (the “incomplete” or “reduced” data), whereas some of the cases and controls provide measurements on X and W (the “complete” data). We assume a measurement error density with a finite set of parameters α, namely f w|xD (w|x, d, α) , and nondifferential error is treated as a special case of this model, f w|x (w|X, α) . Our algorithm estimates both the logistic parameters and α from a pseudolikelihood. Because empirical distribution functions are used in place of needed distributions in the pseudolikelihoods, the required asymptotic theory is more elaborate than for pseudolikelihoods based on substitution for a finite number of nuisance parameters. We also examine computationally simpler methods under the assumptions that the disease is rare and that errors are nondifferential. Estimates of m(W) = E(X|W) are substituted for X in the logistic model when X is not available. Such estimates of m(W) can be obtained from the complete data described above or from an independent validation study. If measurements on X are not available, m(W) can still be estimated from replicated W measurements in some circumstances. A final approach uses approximate logistic regression techniques and is appropriate when a more accurate approximation is required than obtained by simply substituting m(W) for X . Asymptotic theory is presented for each of these procedures, and examples are used to illustrate the calculations.
Enable JavaScript for citation tools and additional paper interactions.