A Robust Test for Non-nested Hypotheses

Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series B (Statistical Methodology) · 1997 · Volume 59 · Issue 3

Abstract

We propose a robust version of Cox-type test statistics for the choice between two non-nested hypotheses. We first show that the influence of small amounts of contamination in the data on the test decision can be very large. Secondly, we build a robust test statistic by using the results on robust parametric tests that are available in the literature and show that the level of the robust test is stable. Finally, we show numerically not only the robustness of this new test statistic but also that its asymptotic distribution is a good approximation of its sample distribution, unlike for the classical test statistic. We apply our results to the choice between a Pareto and an exponential distribution as well as between two competing regressors in the simple linear regression model without intercept.

Keywords

Linear regression, M-estimators, Model choice, Pareto distribution, Robust tests

Enable JavaScript for citation tools and additional paper interactions.