Reinforcing Political Inequality Through Diversity Initiatives: A Field-Level Perspective

Journal of Management · 2024 · Volume 50 · Issue 3

DOI: 10.1177/01492063231163579

Abstract

Although diversity initiatives are considered prominent vessels for addressing inequality and despite massive investments in them, inequality inside organizations persists. Assessments of diversity initiatives often center on economic inequality and view organizations as closed systems to explain why they fail. Building on a 19-month field-level ethnography of the diversity field in Israel targeting Palestinian employment, we examine political inequality and show how it is perpetuated even as economic inequality is dealt with. Our findings reveal that the field is complicit in creating a chasm between the economic and political spheres by positioning diversity initiatives as a means to tackle economic inequality. The field’s infrastructure and dominant discourse reinforce this chasm and thereby make political inequality invisible, generating false consciousness. Our study challenges the preoccupation of diversity scholarship with universal best practices, suggests avenues for assessing and managing diversity initiatives while taking stock of political inequality, and directs future research to delve into the relationship between the economic and the political in organizations and our societies.

Keywords

diversity, inclusion, political inequality, economic inequality, Israeli–Palestinian conflict

Enable JavaScript for citation tools and additional paper interactions.