Do Infants Really Expect Agents to Act Efficiently? A Critical Test of the Rationality Principle

Psychological Science · 2013 · Volume 24 · Issue 4

Abstract

Recent experiments have suggested that infants’ expectations about the actions of agents are guided by a principle of rationality: In particular, infants expect agents to pursue their goals efficiently, expending as little effort as possible. However, these experiments have all presented infants with infrequent or odd actions, which leaves the results open to alternative interpretations and makes it difficult to determine whether infants possess a general expectation of efficiency. We devised a critical test of the rationality principle that did not involve infrequent or odd actions. In two experiments, 16-month-olds watched events in which an agent faced two identical goal objects; although both objects could be reached by typical, everyday actions, one object was physically (Experiment 1) or mentally (Experiment 2) more accessible than the other. In both experiments, infants expected the agent to select the more-accessible object. These results provide new evidence that infants possess a general and robust expectation of efficiency.

Keywords

rationality, efficiency, goals, psychological reasoning, infant cognition, cognitive development, infant development, social cognition

Enable JavaScript for citation tools and additional paper interactions.