From Slum Tourism to Smiley Selfies: The Role of Social Identity Strength in the Consumption of Morally Ambiguous Experiences

Julia Von Schuckmann, Lucia S. G. Barros, Rodrigo S. Dias, Eduardo B. Andrade

Journal of Consumer Psychology · 2018 · Volume 28 · Issue 2

Abstract

Why do some consumers find a consumption activity appealing while others see it as morally appalling? A series of five experiments in two different morally ambiguous contexts shows that differences in social identity strength can in part explain discrepant reactions to the very same consumption experience. Consumers who identify weakly (vs. strongly) with the people most related to the consumption environment are less likely to question the experience on moral grounds. As a result, they are more likely to choose a morally ambiguous consumption experience or to act in a morally ambiguous manner. The impact of social identity strength on consumer preference vanishes when the consumption experience is morally neutral or when all consumers are prompted to judge the experience on moral grounds. Statistical analyses based on post hoc justifications provide further evidence for the mediating role of moral considerations.

Keywords

Morality, Social identity, Unethical consumption, Moral sensitivity, Moral consideration

Enable JavaScript for citation tools and additional paper interactions.