Scholion.ai

Efficient Matching in the School Choice Problem

Philip J. Reny

American Economic Review · 2022 · Volume 112 · Issue 6

DOI: 10.1257/aer.20210240

Abstract

Stable matchings in school choice needn't be Pareto efficient and can leave thousands of students worse off than necessary. Call a matching μ priority-neutral if no matching can make any student whose priority is violated by μ better off without violating the priority of some student who is made worse off. Call a matching priority-efficient if it is priority-neutral and Pareto efficient. We show that there is a unique priority-efficient matching and that it dominates every priority-neutral matching and every stable matching. Moreover, truth-telling is a maxmin optimal strategy for every student in the mechanism that selects the priority-efficient matching.

Keywords

Bargaining Theory, Matching Theory, Analysis of Education, Education: Government Policy

Enable JavaScript for citation tools and additional paper interactions.